The age old pub debate of who has the better sides, Northern or Southern hemisphere is usually settled by the assertion that the Southern hemisphere sides have the upper hand at international level. Countless hours and several pints have been spent wondering where the best club side would hail from. Finally we might have a way to find out rather than just guessing that Super 14’s is of a higher standard because of the impact Rocky Elsom made in the Heineken Cup versus his contribution this year in the Super 14’s. I won’t get into the arguments over ridulous scores in the Super 14’s versus defensive rugby in the Heineken Cup.
The battle of the hemispheres is now firmly on the IRB’s agenda. This would seem obvious when you consider how lucrative the match or mini tournament would be. There are of course some very obvious stumbling blocks. When and where would the tournament take place? The talk at present is for December, but this would heavily favour the Northern teams as it is right in the middle of their season.
What format would the tournament take? A once off match between the respective title winners is an obvious option but the more lucrative option for all involved would be a mini tournament involving the top Australian, South African, All Black, English, French, Magners League and Heineken Cup winners.
The Guardian newspaper has reported that “all the major unions” are behind the proposal and stepping up efforts to get the much-anticipated contest over the line. They say it will be staged somewhere in Europe, and possibly in early December, tagged on the end of the “autumn” international series.
Premier Rugby Limited (PRL), the group representing leading English clubs, are apparently taking a lead role in discussions, keen to establish the playoff as a valuable revenue boost, and also to head off independent interests.
PRL chief executive Mark McCafferty told The Guardian, “Our clubs, as well as those in Europe and the southern hemisphere, have had approaches from Monaco, Abu Dhabi and, most recently, from South Africa. If the stakeholders within rugby don’t create this, somebody else will and we’ll find an outsider coming in.
“It’s us who have been pushing it,” he added. “The only issue we’re trying to crack is the date. The sticking points at the moment are the dates of the new domestic competitions in the southern hemisphere, but we’re still working on it.”
McCafferty felt logistics were all that now stood in the way of the lucrative world playoff.
“Everyone has got an appetite to do it if we can just find a date. Further discussions are continuing with the southern hemisphere to see if we can find one.”
New South Wales Waratahs chief executive Jim L’Estrange told The Australian newspaper they had been approached “about six to eight months ago” about an inter-hemipshere clash of the champions. But they have a bigger concept in mind.
“Rather than having just a one-off match between the two champions, we had in mind a mini-tournament involving five or six teams,” said L’Estrange.
Finding a common ground among all the self-interest is going to be the toughest challenge for officials from both hemispheres.
Staging the match in December suits the north as all their clubs are back in the swing of their competitions, and on the tail of the “autumn” internationals there would be an appetite for a clash of such international standing. However, expecting sides like the Crusaders or Bulls to be able to perform at a level that would make them competitive months after the end of their season, when their players are all in test mode, would be a tall order.
And clearly the Australian unions, less than confident about their involvement as champions of the expanded Super 15, are seeking a guaranteed place as a conference winner.
Whether there is room, or appetite, to grow the concept into a two or three-match playoff must be heavily doubtful but it would at last take the argument as to who is the best in the world out of the pub and onto the pitch.